ampage Tube Amps / Music Electronics	For current discussions, please visit Music Electronics Forum.

ampage archive

Vintage threads from the first ten years

previous: Jim Martin I have been to probably 200 differe... -- 5/31/2000 3:32 AM

Re: Point to Point versus PCB

5/31/2000 2:30 PM
pgambon	Re: Point to Point versus PCB I'd say that PCB are probably better for complex designs. But, I question the need for complex designs in guitar amps. I like basic "one trick pony amps" (ie fender tweed, plexi, and well.. OK black face fenders). With simple designs PTP seems better for maintenance and longevety. Soundwise I think PCB could, if done properly (big "if"), sound better. Recently I worked on a Marshall JCM 2000. I couldn't help but think, what will happen to this amp in 10 or 20 years? Who will be able to fix this and will replacement boards be available? I think there's no reason that a 50's or 60's PTP amps won't continue to survive for many lifetimes. That's where I'd put my money. ps: I agree with the comments about guitar players complaining about the price of high end amps. A Kendrick, Matchless/whatever, will last your lifetime and most likely your heirs childrens too.

5/31/2000 2:30 PM

pgambon

Re: Point to Point versus PCB

I'd say that PCB are probably better for complex designs. But, I question the need for complex designs in guitar amps. I like basic "one trick pony amps" (ie fender tweed, plexi, and well.. OK black face fenders). With simple designs PTP seems better for maintenance and longevety. Soundwise I think PCB could, if done properly (big "if"), sound better.
Recently I worked on a Marshall JCM 2000. I couldn't help but think, what will happen to this amp in 10 or 20 years? Who will be able to fix this and will replacement boards be available? I think there's no reason that a 50's or 60's PTP amps won't continue to survive for many lifetimes. That's where I'd put my money.
ps: I agree with the comments about guitar players complaining about the price of high end amps. A Kendrick, Matchless/whatever, will last your lifetime and most likely your heirs childrens too.