ampage
Tube Amps / Music Electronics
For current discussions, please visit Music Electronics Forum. New: visit Schematic Hell!
 
The sunn still shines online!

ampage archive

Vintage threads from the first ten years

Search for:  Mode:  
previous: dale EV12L vs EV SRO -- 4/29/2000 12:05 AM View Thread

Speaker Comparison

4/29/2000 3:30 PM
Ray Ivers
Speaker Comparison
Dale,  
 
Here I go applying the "kiss of death" to another favorite speaker...  
 
Have you ever heard the EVM-12S? About 8 years ago I got a wild hare up my ass and decided to do a 'mega-speaker shootout', so I got four Marshall 4-12 cabs and put in the following speakers (2 each), with separate jacks to each pair, and I footswitched back and forth for all combinations below over the course of a few months (below each are my super-nutshell comments, pure opinion, from memory):  
 
Celestion Rola G12M-25 (original 70's - 003 cones)  
 
crunchy, slightly raspy, not very loud, a little bland compared to newer speakers  
 
Celestion pre-Rola G12H-25 (014 cones)  
 
tired, cardboardy, lifeless compared to the others; I think maybe these older speakers should be only compared among themselves  
 
Celestion G12H-100 CE (cambric-edge)  
 
loud, NO PE rasp, great bass, no accentuation of 'fuzz' frequencies, my favorite Celestion (discontinued, of course)  
 
Celestion Sidewinder  
 
loud, a little PE (paper-edge) rasp, great for a clean sound and dirty sound at high volumes, good bass, real aggressive sounding  
 
Celestion Vintage 30  
 
fair bass and low mids, a litte raspy, not real loud, didn't seem to have much 'character' to me  
 
JBL E-120  
 
real loud, nice smooth mids, a little bass-shy, great speaker-induced string sustain from all angles, not super bright (surprisingly), better for dirty than clean IMO!  
 
EVM-12S  
 
great bass, very balanced, no mid peak, very nice non-raspy highs (cone is shaped like a trumpet) - the best EV I've heard by far  
 
EVM-12L  
 
seems like a PA speaker to me, good bass, quite loud, great for clean but seemed edgy dirty  
 
How's that for way more than you asked for? I'm somewhat ashamed to admit that I'm not sure what an EV SRO speaker is - is that the same as an OEM EV with no magnet sticker, which I always thought was identical to an EVM, or a different speaker altogether?  
 
Ray

 
Replies:
Tim Swartz The SR0s are from the late '60s ear... -- 4/29/2000 5:27 PM